Whatever Happened to Taking “Underwater” Mortgages?

A funny thing about the press and media. Sometimes they pick up an idea and go on about it, assuring us that it is important and bids fair to influence public events in a profound way. But then poof! After a period of pontificating about it, the news item sort of vanishes from the printed page never to be heard about again.

For example, whatever happened to the bright idea of taking mortgages on “underwater” homes by eminent domain, restructuring the debt secured by those mortgages, and then selling the subject homes for a new, lower price that would still put a buck in the pockets of the city hall promoters of this goofy idea. But in spite of a flurry of articles by out-of-it professors and their press followers, it didn’t happen. The problem with this wacky scheme was that a condemnor acquiring property by eminent domain has to pay fair market value, which would leave no room for making a profit — someone would have to subsidize such a scheme and no one was willing to do so.

So, to the best of our knowledge, it didn’t happen.